Do We Really Need Remakes

If the recent Nintendo Direct is anything to go by then yes, double yes!

Remaking games has always divided opinion amongst the gaming community. A lot of people see it as the video game company in question being lazy and trying to make easy money off of an older game that was popular back in the day. Some worry that the charm of the game won’t transfer to an updated look or indeed be relevant to a younger audience who never had the pleasure of playing the game around release time. You could also argue that companies do this because they have run out of ideas for new IP’s. Let’s get stuck in and check out some recent examples!


Pokémon Let’s Go


I’m in the camp of, I’m happy for remakes if they are relevant and they are handled with the love and attention they deserve. Take the recent Pokémon Let’s go! which was released late last year, there was a lot of resistance to this Pokemon Yellow remake from 1998. So-called ‘hardcore Pokémon’ players were up in arms that Game Freak (the developers) were remaking this classic instead of concentrating on the next successive Pokémon game (Generation 8). They even dared to change the catching mechanics from a turn-based battle style to a proper catching mechanic akin the one used in the extremely popular mobile title Pokémon Go! This turned out to be a masterstroke, not only did it improve the catching style, but it brought something from Pokémon Go! which was familiar for the younger player who this might have been their first experience of Pokémon.

Game Freak stayed true to the original, while still managing to make it relevant to the current generation of gamers, thus giving the game appeal to both young and old. All this aside, Pokémon Let’s Go! Looked fantastic too and played great. It quenched my nostalgic thirst while also feeling like a new game. It sold fantastically well and was received well by all. A good job all around.


Resident Evil 2


The most recent remake was Resident Evil 2. While I never had the pleasure of playing this or the original, I kept a close eye on it and indeed Jill, one of our writers, wrote a detailed review. One thing I do remember from Resi 2 was the early 3D polygon graphics which age far worse than pixel styles so the graphical changes were welcomed with open arms. In fact Capcom created the remake from scratch, duplicating the entire game from the ground up, and it looks fantastic. It’s not a carbon copy however, it’s been tweaked in places. Slight changes to the storyline for coherence and little changes to environmental aspects. The biggest change was the fact the first Resi 2 was made with a fixed camera angle, this had its pros and cons, notably heightening the scare factor while also making it difficult to manoeuvre. The remake deployed a modern familiarity in the over the shoulder camera style, more like the 3rd person games we are used to nowadays. With that being said it did run the risk of losing the charm of the original and being ‘just another 3rd person shooter’ but it also had to be relevant to a modern and new audience that it wanted to sell to.

All in all the Resi 2 was a resounding success both critically and commercially. We rated it 9/10 and we were not alone in rating it so highly. Capcom did the difficult task of staying true to what was loved by the original, while still making it relevant and appealing to newer people to the franchise.


The Legend of Zelda: Links Awakening


So on to the inspiration of this article, Zelda. At the end of last weeks Nintendo Direct we were given a trailer to beat all trailers, Link battling the high seas in the style of the older Japanese box art. He’s then seen floating adrift a small island with an egg atop a volcano with the words we were waiting for, The Legend of Zelda: Links Awakening. This was followed by a few short scenes of gameplay which had me stunned. I don’t mind admitting that I was as giddy as a school girl, not just because it’s Zelda, but because this game was huge for me growing up. I had this back in 1993 at release on the original GameBoy and it was my absolute favourite game on the system, more so than Pokémon which released later in the decade. This was my first taste of Zelda and I loved everything about this game, the story, the graphics, the puzzles and dungeons, even the funny little characters and wit of the writing. It’s an adventure that will always stay with me.

This remake looks stunning, absolutely. Yes it’s been 26 years and yes it couldn’t look more different to the original but it is still instantly recognisable as Links Awakening, unmistakably. Even seeing the little BowWow protecting the house like a guard dog brought back fond memories for me. The introduction of this remake has been widely welcomed, with a few critics calling the art style too cutsie. This game is totally different to Breath Of The Wild which was a gritty adventure of self-discovery. Links Awakening is about Links hunt for the instruments of the sirens to awaken the Wind Fish thus allowing him to escape the island, no Hyrule and no Ganon and is more like a dream, therefore I feel the new style is fitting. Link almost looks like a wooden figure, painted to perfection. It looks totally stunning and I can’t wait to return to Koholint Island.


Best of the Rest



Many other games have been, or are being remade. Most notably Final Fantasy 7 which is for many one of the greatest games ever. However, I fear I’ll never see it in my lifetime as it’s constantly delayed! Shadow of the Colossus was remade last year too with rave reviews, and a decent price at launch to boot. Let’s not forget Tomb Raider which has also seen a reboot in recent times. I am welcoming all these remakes, they are fresh and relevant to today’s audience while staying true to the originals. It brings games worth playing to people who won’t necessarily search out the originals


What games would you personally like to see remade? Do you agree with remaking games or would you prefer developers to stick to new content? Let us know in the comments section below, on Twitter or our Facebook page!

4 thoughts on “Do We Really Need Remakes

Add yours

  1. I think you’re example of resident evil 2 is very misleading, especially if someone who hasn’t seen/heard about the game finds this.

    You stated that resi 2 has “Slight changes to the storyline for coherence and little changes to environmental aspects”. This couldn’t be farther from the truth. The story does follow the same general storyline, but other than that it doesn’t play out the same way, almost at all. As for the environment, there are some places in the game that feel familiar. However that is limited to only the police station, and even then the familiar parts have been reworked to incorporate new rooms as well. The parking garage, sewer, and laboratory have almost nothing in common with the original game.

    I understand you haven’t played original or the remake, but if you’re going to use it as an example for an article, you should have. You really undersold the game, as more than “a little” was done to the story and environments. Writing an article with blatant mistakes That could have been easily researched comes off as a rookie move.


    1. Hi Richard, sorry if you didn’t like what you read or thought I was misleading, that wasn’t my intention. I did say I hadn’t played either game but I thought it was a high profile game that needed mentioning. I included what people had told me about the game in discussions and as it wasn’t a review I didn’t feel the need to go into too much depth. I just wanted an overall discussion about remakes. My inspiration for the article was the Zelda announcement and it wasn’t really my intention to write about Resi 2 at all. Maybe next time I won’t include something if I don’t have first hand knowledge. Sorry you didn’t enjoy what I wrote but I really do value peoples feedback so thank you for A) taking the time to read what I wrote and B) for pointing out where I could have improved the article. All the best!


  2. Fab article! Remakes are so contentious because we all get attached to things and can get super defensive if someone even considers changing yellow spandex to black body armor. But remakes bring the old to new audiences and if it’s done well I don’t get what the issue is. I never got to play Link’s Awakening (I grew up in a Sega household) and I’m really looking forward to getting the remake.

    If I had to pick a game for remaking, it would have to be Shivers from Sierra Online – my first horror/puzzle game that I still occasionally dream about 😊😊😊

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: